Close Menu
  • Homepage
  • News
  • Cloud & AI
  • ECommerce
  • Entertainment
  • Finance
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Contact

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest technology news from TechFinancials News about FinTech, Tech, Business, Telecoms and Connected Life.

What's Hot

R66 Million Transnet Fraud: Yakub Ahmed Suleman Bhikhu Setenced To 10 Years In Prison

2025-07-18

Dr Naledi Pandor Calls For “Good Trouble” On Nelson Mandela International Day

2025-07-18

PariPesa South Africa: Online Casino And A Sportsbook Combined In One App

2025-07-18
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Trending
  • R66 Million Transnet Fraud: Yakub Ahmed Suleman Bhikhu Setenced To 10 Years In Prison
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn WhatsApp RSS
TechFinancials
  • Homepage
  • News
  • Cloud & AI
  • ECommerce
  • Entertainment
  • Finance
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Contact
TechFinancials
Home»News»Microsoft’s racist chatbot Tay highlights how far AI is from being truly intelligent
News

Microsoft’s racist chatbot Tay highlights how far AI is from being truly intelligent

Gugu LourieBy Gugu Lourie2016-03-28No Comments4 Mins Read
Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email Copy Link

It has been a nightmare of a PR week for Microsoft. It started with the head of Microsoft’s Xbox division, Phil Spencer, having to apologise for having scantily clad female dancers dressed as school girls at a party thrown by Microsoft at the Game Developers Conference (GDC). He said that having the dancers at this event “was absolutely not consistent or aligned to our values. That was unequivocally wrong and will not be tolerated” By David Glance

The matter was being dealt with internally and so we don’t know who would have been responsible and why they might have thought this was going to be a good idea.

But things were going to get much worse for Microsoft when a chatbot called Tay started tweeting offensive comments seemingly supporting Nazi, anti-feminist and racist views. The idea was that the artificial intelligence behind Tay would learn from others on Twitter and other social media networks and appear as an average 19 year old female person. What happened however was that the experiment was hijacked by a group of people from the notorious “pol” (politically incorrect) bulletin board on 4chan and 8chan who set about training Tay to say highly inappropriate things.

This time it was down to Peter Lee, the Corporate Vice President of Microsoft Research who had to say “We are deeply sorry for the unintended offensive and hurtful tweets from Tay, which do not represent who we are or what we stand for”.

Tay was taken down and the tweets deleted but not before some of the most offensive of them were captured and spread even further on the Internet.

Apparently, the researchers at Microsoft thought that because they had successfully developed a similar AI chatbot called XiaoIce that has been running successfully in China on the social network Weibo, that Tay’s experience on Twitter with a western audience would follow the same path.

Caroline Sinders, an AI interaction designer working on IBM’s Watson computer has written a good explanation of how the developers of Tay should have anticipated this outcome and protected against it. There hadn’t been enough testing of the bot and certainly the developers of the technology did not have the sociological skills to understand the range of communities on the Internet and what they would do once the technology was released into the wild.

The disturbing outcome of Tay was that Microsoft’s Peter Lee saw the problem with the Tay “experiment” as being a technological one that could be solved with a simple technology fix. He missed entirely that the problem was a sociological and philosophical one which unless addressed from that perspective, will always result in technology that sounds superficially human but will always stop well short of displaying any real intelligence.

Chatbots are designed to learn about how language is constructed and to use that knowledge to create words that are contextually correct and relevant. They are not taught to understand what those words actually mean, nor to understand the social, moral and ethical dimensions of those words. Tay did not know what a feminist is when it suggested that “they should all die and burn in hell”, it was simply repeating a construct of words that it had input as parts of sentences that it could reformat with a high probability of sounding like it made sense.

It is a testament to human nature’s ability to anthropomorphise technology that we make the leap from something that sounds intelligent to an entity that actually is intelligent. This was recently the case with Google’s AI software AlphaGo which beat a world-class human player at the complex game of Go. Commentary on this suggested that AlphaGo had exhibited many human intelligence characteristics instead of what it did do, which was efficiently searching and computing winning strategies out of the many millions of games that it had access to.

Even the term “learning” that is applied to AI leads many, including the developers of AI itself to assume wrongly that it is equivalent to the learning processes that humans go through. This in turn leads to the risks of what AI experts like Stuart Russell and Peter Norvig have warned about for many years that an “AI system’s learning function may cause it to evolve into a system with unintended behavior”.

The experiment with Tay highlighted the poor judgement of developers at Microsoft as much as the limitations of chatbots. It seems that in this case both humans and software might not learn the real lessons from this unfortunate incident.

The Conversation

  • David Glance, Director of UWA Centre for Software Practice, University of Western Australia
  • This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Gugu Lourie
Gugu Lourie

Related Posts

Mystery Of R3M In Lottery Funds Paid To Athletics South Africa

2025-07-18

SA’s Kariega Plant Thrives As Global Polo Hub

2025-07-18

LEPAS Debuts In South Africa 2026 To Redefine Premium SUVs

2025-07-16

Gwede Mantashe Named Acting Minister Of Police

2025-07-15

Minister Creecy Dissolves RAF Board Over Governance Failures

2025-07-15

Monde Bala Appointed Interim CEO Of National Transmission Company SA

2025-07-15

Government Working To Safeguard The Integrity Effectiveness Of The Police

2025-07-15

Life Healthcare Completes Sale Of Life Molecular Imaging To Lantheus

2025-07-14

President Ramaphosa To Brief The Nation On National Security Matters

2025-07-10
Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

DON'T MISS
Breaking News

R66 Million Transnet Fraud: Yakub Ahmed Suleman Bhikhu Setenced To 10 Years In Prison

Businessman Yakub Ahmed Suleman Bhikhu, who evaded arrest for six years, has been sentenced to…

Volvo Is Opening A Full-Service Dealership In Gqeberha’s Moffett Retail Park

2025-07-17

Rise In E-Commerce Activity Boosts SA’s Supply Chain Sector

2025-07-16

South Africans Spent R20M Via Luno Pay Since Nov 2024 Launch

2025-06-24
Stay In Touch
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn
OUR PICKS

Dr Naledi Pandor Calls For “Good Trouble” On Nelson Mandela International Day

2025-07-18

Fuse Lit: SA’s U.S. Tech Bomb ‘Nears Detonation’

2025-07-16

US Denies Mcebisi Jonas’ Visa, Rejects Credentials As Ramaphosa’s Envoy

2025-07-15

Takealot Expands Pickup Points At Pick n Pay For Shopper Convenience

2025-07-14

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest tech news from TechFinancials about telecoms, fintech and connected life.

About Us

TechFinancials delivers in-depth analysis of tech, digital revolution, fintech, e-commerce, digital banking and breaking tech news.

Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit RSS
Our Picks

R66 Million Transnet Fraud: Yakub Ahmed Suleman Bhikhu Setenced To 10 Years In Prison

2025-07-18

Dr Naledi Pandor Calls For “Good Trouble” On Nelson Mandela International Day

2025-07-18

PariPesa South Africa: Online Casino And A Sportsbook Combined In One App

2025-07-18
Recent Posts
  • R66 Million Transnet Fraud: Yakub Ahmed Suleman Bhikhu Setenced To 10 Years In Prison
  • Dr Naledi Pandor Calls For “Good Trouble” On Nelson Mandela International Day
  • PariPesa South Africa: Online Casino And A Sportsbook Combined In One App
  • Public Warned Of Fake Chief Justice Social Media Profiles
  • Call To Address Widening Insurance Protection Gap
TechFinancials
RSS Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn YouTube WhatsApp
  • Homepage
  • Newsletter
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • About
© 2025 TechFinancials. Designed by TFS Media.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

Ad Blocker Enabled!
Ad Blocker Enabled!
Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors. Please support us by disabling your Ad Blocker.