Close Menu
  • Homepage
  • News
  • Cloud & AI
  • ECommerce
  • Entertainment
  • Finance
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Contact

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest technology news from TechFinancials News about FinTech, Tech, Business, Telecoms and Connected Life.

What's Hot

Remittix Will Produce More Gains For Early Investors Than Pepe Coin & Shiba Inu Did

2025-08-30

Cardano Price Prediction For 2026 & Analysts Predict The Chances Of Dogecoin Reaching $1

2025-08-30

Top Cryptos To Invest In At The End Of August: SUI, Pi Coin, Hedera & Remittix

2025-08-30
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Trending
  • Remittix Will Produce More Gains For Early Investors Than Pepe Coin & Shiba Inu Did
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn WhatsApp RSS
TechFinancials
  • Homepage
  • News
  • Cloud & AI
  • ECommerce
  • Entertainment
  • Finance
  • Opinion
  • Podcast
  • Contact
TechFinancials
Home»News»Mediation Will Unclog Court Backlog, Says Judge
News

Mediation Will Unclog Court Backlog, Says Judge

Judge Stuart WilsonBy Judge Stuart Wilson2025-05-17No Comments5 Mins Read
Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
The Western Cape High Court
The Western Cape High Court has ruled invalid a bequest of millions of rands to a white supremacy group. Archive photo: Ashraf Hendricks
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email Copy Link

I am a high court judge. Every day, I help people resolve their disputes according to law. There’s nothing I don’t like about the work. I find every part of the law interesting. I take genuine pleasure in working out how the law applies to the hundreds of contested cases I have heard, and in giving the parties a decision that will help them on their way.

Still, the litigation process depends on litigants and their lawyers doing a lot of work to define the nature of the dispute I and other judges have to decide, and to produce the evidence that we need to hear to resolve the dispute for them.

At the moment, though, the vast majority of trial actions we are asked to hear are brought to us before they are ready to be heard, because the parties have not done the work necessary to define the dispute they want us to resolve.

As a result, the number of trials in which evidence is actually heard and for which judgment can be given, is a small fraction of the number of trials in which the parties are just not ready, and probably never will be ready, to present their case.

Inevitably, the matter settles or is postponed with nothing having been resolved. When the parties settle at the outset of the trial because they’re not ready to proceed, it takes ten minutes to review and endorse the agreement. But the rest of the time allocated to hear the trial goes to waste. Sometimes it’s the rest of the day. Sometimes it’s the whole week. 

That time could be spent hearing other cases in which people can say exactly what it is they want decided. These are cases in which a judge can actually do their job.

This is what is meant when people say the high court’s trial rolls are “clogged”. There are far too many cases which are not ready to be decided. Many, if not most, of these cases will likely never need to be decided because, once the parties have defined their disputes properly, they often agree how those disputes should be resolved without the need for a judge.

The number of unprepared cases enrolled in my trial court dwarfs the number of cases that are ready to be heard before me. The result is that people who need the court’s help –- some of them desperately –- must wait months or years for a hearing.

Recently, a directive was introduced in the Gauteng division to address this problem. The directive is this: before you get a trial date, you must have attempted to resolve your case through mediation. This means a trained mediator must look at your case and engage with you and your opponent to see if an agreement on how it should be resolved can be reached.

If the matter is resolved, so much the better. If not, the mediator must write a report to the judge in which they certify the matter is not settled, and set out the issues that remain in dispute between the parties. This means when the matter comes to a judge, they will have some idea what the dispute is really about. It also increases the likelihood of the dispute being settled well before the case comes to a hearing. Litigants who know what they’re really arguing about are more likely to settle their differences amicably.

The new directive has been criticised. But I think much of the criticism misses the point.

Some say that the directive breaches the right of access to court. But this misunderstands what that right protects. The right in section 34 of the Constitution is “to have any dispute that can be resolved by the application of law” heard by a court or “another independent and impartial tribunal or forum”. But in order for a dispute to be “resolved by the application of law”, the parties need to have defined the dispute.

Another criticism is that asking the parties to pay for a mediator will make litigation more expensive. I don’t see how. Whether by a mediator or by the parties’ lawyers, a dispute must be defined before it comes to court. Someone must be paid to do the work necessary to get a dispute to the state needed for a judge to resolve it. Mediators may well be able to do that more cheaply than lawyers. And if the dispute is settled, there are no further costs.

It has also been said that the directive is “judicial overreach”. But section 173 of the Constitution gives the High Court the power to protect and regulate its own process. Requiring the parties before the court to define a dispute judges can actually decide is at the very heart of that power.

If the mediation directive is successful, it would speed up trial litigation in Johannesburg and Pretoria by several orders of magnitude. It would make sure people with genuinely justiciable disputes have their cases heard promptly and fairly. It would slash the cost of litigation for those whose disputes can be settled. It would also lower the cost of disputes that ultimately need a judge by more closely defining what it is the judge is required to decide. It would, in other words, expand access to justice to the benefit of thousands of people who must presently wait years longer than they should for their day in court.

  • Stuart Wilson is a judge of the Gauteng High Court.
  • This article was originally published by GroundUp. It is republished by TechFinancials under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International Licence. Read the original article

Courts Mediation Mediation in SA courts
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Judge Stuart Wilson

Related Posts

Zayna Mahomed Is EPF Solve’s For X August Winner 

2025-08-29

Eskom Fraudster Sentenced, Ordered To Repay R2.6M

2025-08-29

WeThinkCode_ Graduates Stand Out In Job Market With Cutting-Edge Industry Electives

2025-08-26

Africa Can Turn Its Minerals Into Green Gold

2025-08-26

SwapVend Launches Its Minimum Viable Product To Bridge SA’s Informal And Formal Economies

2025-08-25

MortgageMarket & Takealot Launch SA’s 1st E-Commerce Home Loan Hub

2025-08-25

Spaza Market Lays The Foundation For Africa’s Enterprise Economy

2025-08-25

Why South Africa Is The Hidden Powerhouse For Global Executive Search

2025-08-25

University Of Pretoria Ranked No. 1 In SA For Artificial Intelligence Research

2025-08-24
Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

DON'T MISS
Breaking News

BankservAfrica Rebrands As PayInc

The financial market infrastructure giant BankservAfrica has officially been rebranded to PayInc. The launch, held…

KZN’s First Supercar-Centric Luxury Residential Development Unveiled

2025-08-27

Government Pensions Administration Agency CEO Placed On Precautionary Suspension

2025-08-26

Airtel Africa & Vodacom Forge Landmark Infrastructure Partnership

2025-08-12
Stay In Touch
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn
OUR PICKS

SA’s Skhokho 2.0 Puts Enterprise AI In SME Hands

2025-08-28

Please Call Me: After 25 Years, Will SCA’s New Bench Silence ConCourt?

2025-08-26

Vodacom Invests R400M To Expand Network In Free State And Northern Cape

2025-08-26

Elon Musk’s Starlink Backs BEE Equity Equivalents, Not 30% Ownership

2025-08-18

Subscribe to Updates

Get the latest tech news from TechFinancials about telecoms, fintech and connected life.

About Us

TechFinancials delivers in-depth analysis of tech, digital revolution, fintech, e-commerce, digital banking and breaking tech news.

Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit RSS
Our Picks

Remittix Will Produce More Gains For Early Investors Than Pepe Coin & Shiba Inu Did

2025-08-30

Cardano Price Prediction For 2026 & Analysts Predict The Chances Of Dogecoin Reaching $1

2025-08-30

Top Cryptos To Invest In At The End Of August: SUI, Pi Coin, Hedera & Remittix

2025-08-30
Recent Posts
  • Remittix Will Produce More Gains For Early Investors Than Pepe Coin & Shiba Inu Did
  • Cardano Price Prediction For 2026 & Analysts Predict The Chances Of Dogecoin Reaching $1
  • Top Cryptos To Invest In At The End Of August: SUI, Pi Coin, Hedera & Remittix
  • Why Remittix, Solana, Avalanche, & Litecoin Are The Best Altcoins To Buy Today
  • Hoskinson Talks Network Future & ADA Plans As Price Drops With Top Investors Eyeing This New Altcoin
TechFinancials
RSS Facebook X (Twitter) LinkedIn YouTube WhatsApp
  • Homepage
  • Newsletter
  • Contact
  • Advertise
  • Privacy Policy
  • About
© 2025 TechFinancials. Designed by TFS Media.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

Ad Blocker Enabled!
Ad Blocker Enabled!
Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors. Please support us by disabling your Ad Blocker.