Facing a criminal accusation in North Texas puts your freedom, career, and reputation on the line immediately. Even before a case reaches a courtroom, an arrest can disrupt your employment, professional licensing, and family stability. Navigating the Dallas County court system—from initial magistration at the Lew Sterrett Justice Center to felony proceedings at the Frank Crowley Courts Building—requires fast action and a clear understanding of your constitutional rights.
To help North Texas residents understand how to protect themselves when accused of a crime, we spoke with David Payma, Dallas criminal defense attorney and founder of Texas Defenders. Recently named the 2026 Law Firm of the Year for Dallas by the Consumer Ratings Institute, Texas Defenders brings former prosecutorial insight and over 1,000 five-star client reviews to misdemeanor and felony defense across the Dallas-Fort Worth metroplex. In this interview, Payma shares practical advice on early case strategy, challenging state evidence, and clearing criminal records under Texas law.
Q: Texas Defenders was recently named the 2026 Law Firm of the Year in Dallas by the Consumer Ratings Institute after earning more than 1,000 five-star reviews. What specific client communication practices drive that level of trust during a high-stress criminal case?
David Payma: One of the things I’ve always emphasized at Texas Defenders is that being a great criminal defense attorney isn’t just about what happens in the courtroom. It’s also about how you treat your clients throughout the process. When someone is arrested or charged with a crime, they’re often experiencing one of the most stressful periods of their life. They’re worried about their freedom, their job, their family, and their future. The last thing they should have to worry about is whether their attorney is going to return their phone call.
We’ve worked hard to build a culture where communication and responsiveness are just as important as legal knowledge and courtroom experience. That starts with accessibility. We want clients to know they can reach our team, get answers to their questions, and understand what’s happening with their case. We emphasize returning calls promptly, keeping clients informed about important developments, and explaining the legal process in plain English rather than overwhelming people with legal terminology.
Another important part of our approach is setting realistic expectations. I believe one of the biggest mistakes an attorney can make is telling a client what they want to hear instead of what they need to hear. Criminal cases can be unpredictable, and no ethical attorney can guarantee a particular outcome. Our responsibility is to give clients an honest assessment of their situation, explain their options, and develop the strongest defense strategy possible based on the facts and the law.
We also recognize that every client is different. Someone facing their first DWI arrest in Dallas may have completely different concerns than someone charged with a serious felony in Collin County or Tarrant County. We try to understand what’s most important to each person, whether that’s protecting their career, avoiding a criminal conviction, or minimizing the impact on their family. That personal attention makes a tremendous difference.
As we’ve grown and handled more than 4,000 criminal cases, maintaining that level of service has required us to be intentional about hiring the right people, developing internal systems, and holding our team accountable. I want every person who contacts Texas Defenders to feel that their case matters, regardless of the charge they’re facing.
Being named the 2026 Law Firm of the Year in Dallas by the Consumer Ratings Institute and earning more than 1,000 five-star reviews is something I’m incredibly proud of. But what makes those reviews meaningful to me is that they represent real people who trusted us during some of the most difficult moments of their lives.
Ultimately, I think trust comes down to doing what you say you’re going to do. Answer the phone. Return the call. Be honest. Show up prepared. Keep your clients informed. And most importantly, never forget that behind every criminal case is a real person whose future matters.
That’s the standard we’ve worked to establish at Texas Defenders, and it’s something I take personally.
Q: Your firm emphasizes beginning a criminal defense strategy immediately rather than waiting for a trial date. What critical evidence—such as body-camera footage, traffic stop legality, or lab testing—can be lost or overlooked if a person delays hiring an attorney?
David Payma: One of the biggest misconceptions people have about criminal defense is that the real work begins when you walk into a courtroom. In reality, some of the most important opportunities to defend a criminal case happen in the hours and days immediately following an arrest.
At Texas Defenders, we believe in being proactive rather than reactive. The earlier a criminal defense attorney gets involved, the more opportunities there may be to preserve evidence, investigate the allegations, and identify weaknesses in the prosecution’s case before critical information disappears.
Take a DWI arrest in Dallas, for example. There may be police body-camera footage, dashcam recordings, surveillance video from nearby businesses, or footage from the location where the traffic stop occurred. Some of that evidence is subject to retention policies and may eventually be overwritten or deleted. An experienced Dallas DWI lawyer can take steps to request preservation of that evidence before it’s lost.
We also examine whether law enforcement had a lawful basis to initiate a traffic stop, extend a detention, conduct a search, or make an arrest. Just because someone was arrested doesn’t mean every action taken by the police was constitutional. Identifying those issues early allows us to investigate the circumstances while evidence is still available and witnesses’ memories are fresh.
Scientific evidence is another critical area. In DWI cases, that can mean reviewing breathalyzer maintenance and calibration records, blood collection procedures, laboratory testing methods, and the chain of custody. In drug possession cases, we may need to examine how substances were collected, stored, and analyzed. Lab results aren’t automatically infallible, and the procedures used to obtain them can be just as important as the results themselves.
In assault and domestic violence cases, early intervention can be particularly important. Text messages, social media communications, photographs, surveillance footage, and witness statements may provide context that isn’t reflected in the initial police report. Sometimes evidence supporting a client’s defense exists outside the information law enforcement initially collected. The longer someone waits, the harder that evidence may be to recover.
There are also important legal deadlines that people don’t always realize exist. For example, following certain DWI arrests in Texas, a person may have as little as 15 days from receiving notice to request an Administrative License Revocation hearing to challenge a driver’s license suspension. Missing that deadline can have consequences separate from the criminal case.
Another point I emphasize is that hiring a criminal defense lawyer early isn’t just about preparing for trial. In some situations, an attorney may be able to communicate with investigators or prosecutors before formal charges are filed, present favorable evidence, or address weaknesses in the allegations. Every case is different, and there are no guarantees, but those early opportunities can be extremely valuable.
Ultimately, when someone’s freedom, career, and reputation are at stake, time matters. My advice to anyone facing a criminal investigation or arrest is simple: don’t wait until you have a court date to start protecting your future.
Q: Many people assume a DWI breath or blood test over the legal limit or video of an offense leaves them with no real defense options. How do you evaluate and challenge the state’s evidence in these cases across Dallas, Collin, Tarrant, and Denton counties?
David Payma: One of the biggest misconceptions about criminal defense is that if the police have a video of an alleged offense or a breath or blood test showing someone was over the legal limit, the case is essentially over. That’s simply not true. At Texas Defenders, we believe the government’s evidence should always be examined critically, regardless of how convincing it might initially appear.
In DWI cases, for example, people often assume that a blood alcohol concentration above 0.08 automatically guarantees a conviction. But a test result is only one piece of evidence, and there are numerous factors that can affect its reliability and admissibility. Our Dallas DWI defense attorneys examine everything from the legality of the initial traffic stop to how field sobriety tests were conducted, whether breath-testing equipment was properly maintained, and whether blood samples were collected, stored, and analyzed according to appropriate procedures.
Timing can also be critical. Someone’s blood alcohol concentration at the time of testing may be different from what it was when they were actually driving. We examine those differences, along with the underlying laboratory data, chain of custody, and any potential errors in the testing process. Scientific evidence can be powerful, but it isn’t infallible.
Video evidence presents another interesting challenge. People tend to believe that if something was caught on camera, there is nothing left to argue. But video doesn’t always tell the entire story. A recording may capture only a few seconds of an encounter without showing what happened before or afterward. Camera angles, lighting, audio quality, and missing context can dramatically affect how an incident is interpreted.
In assault and domestic violence cases, for example, a video might show a physical confrontation without revealing who initiated it, whether someone was acting in self-defense, or what occurred immediately before the recording began. In other criminal cases, video may show certain actions without establishing the intent required to prove the offense. Just because someone appears on camera doesn’t necessarily mean the prosecution can establish every element of a criminal charge beyond a reasonable doubt.
That’s why our attorneys don’t simply watch a video and accept the prosecution’s interpretation. We compare it against police reports, witness statements, physical evidence, timestamps, and other available recordings. We also examine how the evidence was obtained, whether it has been preserved in its original form, and whether there are legitimate questions about its authenticity, completeness, or admissibility.
I also believe it’s important to be realistic. Not every case has a constitutional violation, not every video can be challenged successfully, and not every blood test contains an error. Our responsibility is to investigate thoroughly, identify legitimate defenses, and give clients an honest assessment of their options rather than making promises we can’t guarantee.
At Texas Defenders, we don’t confuse evidence with proof of guilt. The government still has the burden of proving every element of a criminal offense beyond a reasonable doubt, and our job is to hold it to that standard.
Q: Your legal team includes attorneys with former prosecutorial experience. How does understanding how the government investigates and charges offenses give your clients an advantage during negotiations or grand jury proceedings?
David Payma: I think one of the biggest advantages a criminal defense attorney can have is understanding how the other side thinks. When you’ve worked as a prosecutor, you understand how criminal cases are investigated, how charging decisions are made, what evidence prosecutors consider important, and what weaknesses might cause them to reconsider a case.
At Texas Defenders, having former prosecutorial experience on our team gives us an additional perspective when evaluating criminal allegations. Rather than simply reacting to the charges filed against our clients, we try to anticipate how the prosecution is building its case, what evidence it will rely on, and where its arguments may be vulnerable.
One thing people don’t always understand is that an arrest doesn’t necessarily mean formal criminal charges will follow. In many cases, particularly felony investigations, there can be opportunities for a criminal defense attorney to get involved before an indictment. That early involvement can be incredibly important.
For example, when appropriate, we may be able to communicate with prosecutors before a case is presented to a grand jury, provide evidence that wasn’t included in the initial police investigation, identify inconsistencies in witness statements, or present information that supports a client’s innocence or raises questions about the allegations. In some circumstances, that can influence how prosecutors evaluate the case, whether charges are pursued, or what charges are ultimately presented. Of course, prosecutors control charging decisions, and the grand jury makes its own determination about whether probable cause exists to indict.
I think that’s an important distinction because many people assume that once they’re arrested, their only option is to wait for their court date and see what happens. In reality, some of the most valuable criminal defense work can happen long before a case ever reaches a courtroom.
Former prosecutorial experience can also be particularly useful during negotiations. Prosecutors evaluate cases based on the strength of the evidence, the applicable law, potential defenses, witness credibility, and the likelihood of proving the charges at trial. Understanding that process helps us have more productive conversations about weaknesses in the government’s case and potential resolutions.
I also think it’s important to recognize that having a former prosecutor on your team doesn’t mean you have special influence over the district attorney’s office or that you can guarantee a particular outcome. What it means is that you bring another level of understanding to the process, and that knowledge can help you identify opportunities that might otherwise be overlooked.
Ultimately, our goal isn’t simply to defend clients against the charges they’ve already received. It’s to look for every legitimate opportunity to protect them before those charges define their future.
That’s the philosophy we’ve built Texas Defenders around. We want to be proactive, strategic, and prepared at every stage of the criminal justice process, whether that means challenging an investigation before indictment, negotiating with prosecutors, or taking a case to trial when necessary.
Q: Common misconceptions often hurt people after an arrest, such as assuming an alleged victim can simply drop an assault charge or that a dismissal automatically erases an arrest record. What are the biggest legal pitfalls you see clients make early on, and how can they avoid them?
David Payma: One of the most frustrating things I see as a criminal defense attorney is people unintentionally making their situations worse because they misunderstand how the criminal justice system works. Most people have never been arrested before, and much of what they think they know about criminal law comes from television, social media, or advice from friends and family. Unfortunately, some of those misconceptions can have serious consequences.
One of the biggest misconceptions involves assault and domestic violence cases. People frequently believe that if the alleged victim wants to drop the charges, the case will automatically go away. That’s not how it works in Texas. Once law enforcement becomes involved, the decision to pursue criminal charges generally rests with the prosecutor, not the person who made the original accusation.
We regularly encounter situations where the parties have reconciled, the alleged victim doesn’t want to cooperate, or someone wants to take back an earlier statement. While those circumstances may affect how a case is evaluated, they don’t automatically require the district attorney to dismiss the charges. Prosecutors can sometimes proceed using 911 recordings, body-camera footage, photographs, medical records, or other evidence even without the alleged victim’s cooperation. That’s why it’s so important to involve an experienced assault or domestic violence defense attorney rather than assuming the situation will resolve itself.
Another major mistake is talking too much after an arrest. People naturally want to explain their side of the story, especially when they believe they’ve been falsely accused. But statements made to police, investigators, or even friends and family can sometimes become evidence against them. Jail phone calls are particularly dangerous because they’re generally recorded, with the exception of properly protected attorney-client communications. My advice is to clearly invoke your right to remain silent, ask for an attorney, and avoid discussing the facts of your case until you’ve received legal advice.
Social media creates another set of problems. We’ve seen how text messages, social media posts, photographs, and online conversations can become important evidence in criminal investigations. Something that seems harmless to the person posting it may be interpreted very differently by law enforcement or prosecutors. I always encourage people facing criminal allegations to be extremely careful about what they say publicly and to avoid discussing their cases online. They also shouldn’t delete potentially relevant messages or evidence, because doing so can create additional legal problems.
Another misconception is that getting a criminal case dismissed automatically clears your record. In Texas, an arrest can remain visible on a person’s criminal history even after the underlying charges are dismissed. Depending on the circumstances, someone may need to pursue an expunction or another form of record relief to address that history. Eligibility depends on the case, and not every dismissal immediately qualifies. This is particularly important because an arrest record can affect employment opportunities, professional licensing, housing, and someone’s reputation long after the criminal case has ended.
People also underestimate the importance of complying with bond conditions and court orders. In domestic violence cases, for example, a judge may issue a protective order or impose restrictions on contact with certain individuals. Even if the other person initiates contact or wants to reconcile, violating an applicable court order can create serious consequences. The safest approach is to understand exactly what restrictions apply and follow them until they’re legally modified or lifted.
Finally, one of the biggest mistakes is waiting too long to hire a criminal defense attorney. People sometimes assume that if they haven’t been formally charged, or if their first court date is months away, there’s no urgency. But evidence can disappear, witnesses’ memories can fade, and important deadlines can pass. In DWI cases, for example, there can be a very short window to request a hearing to challenge an administrative driver’s license suspension.
The advice I give people is simple: don’t assume you understand the legal process, don’t try to talk your way out of a criminal investigation, and don’t wait until the situation becomes more serious before getting legal help.
Ultimately, an arrest doesn’t have to define someone’s future, but protecting that future often starts with making the right decisions early on.
Q: Beyond beating or reducing the immediate charge, your firm focuses on protecting a client’s long-term future. How do options like deferred adjudication, expunction, and orders of nondisclosure work in Texas to safeguard someone’s career and reputation?
David Payma: One of the things I’ve always emphasized at Texas Defenders is that a successful criminal defense isn’t just about what happens in the courtroom. It’s about what happens to our clients five, ten, or twenty years down the road. A criminal charge can affect someone’s ability to get a job, maintain a professional license, find housing, or pursue educational opportunities. That’s why we look beyond the immediate charges and focus on protecting our clients’ long-term futures.
A lot of people don’t realize that even when a criminal case is dismissed, the arrest itself can remain on their record. That means someone who was never convicted of a crime may still have to explain an arrest to a potential employer or deal with the consequences of a background check. To me, that’s one of the most frustrating aspects of the criminal justice system, and it’s why understanding the options available under Texas law is so important.
One option we evaluate is deferred adjudication. In certain criminal cases, deferred adjudication allows a person to be placed on community supervision without the judge immediately entering a finding of guilt. If the individual successfully completes the conditions imposed by the court, the case can be dismissed without a final conviction. However, deferred adjudication isn’t available for every offense, and it doesn’t automatically erase the case from someone’s criminal history. That’s an important distinction that people need to understand before accepting a plea agreement.
Another option is expunction, which is one of the most powerful forms of criminal record relief available in Texas. When someone qualifies for an expunction, the law generally allows records relating to an arrest to be removed from the criminal history systems and records maintained by covered agencies. Expunction may be available in certain cases involving dismissals, acquittals, or arrests that never resulted in formal charges, depending on the circumstances and applicable legal requirements. For someone trying to move forward with their career or personal life, that can make an enormous difference.
Texas also offers orders of nondisclosure, which can limit public access to certain criminal history records. This option may be available to some individuals who successfully complete deferred adjudication or meet other statutory requirements. Unlike expunction, nondisclosure doesn’t destroy the records, and certain government agencies and authorized entities may still access them. But for eligible individuals, it can provide meaningful protection against having a past criminal case appear in many routine public background checks.
What makes these options especially important is that the decisions made at the beginning of a criminal case can affect whether someone qualifies for record relief years later. A plea agreement that seems attractive because it avoids jail time may have consequences for a person’s professional license, employment opportunities, or future eligibility for expunction or nondisclosure. That’s why we believe a criminal defense attorney should consider the long-term consequences before recommending any resolution.
I think that’s something that distinguishes our approach to criminal defense. We don’t view clients as case numbers or simply focus on getting them through their next court appearance. We want to understand how a criminal accusation could affect their entire life and develop a defense strategy with those consequences in mind.
Of course, not everyone qualifies for deferred adjudication, expunction, or an order of nondisclosure. Texas law has specific eligibility requirements, exceptions, and waiting periods, and certain offenses carry restrictions that make record relief unavailable. Part of our responsibility is being honest about those limitations while identifying every legitimate opportunity to protect our clients.
I’ve always believed that the true measure of a successful criminal defense isn’t just the outcome of the case. It’s whether we’ve helped put our client in the strongest possible position to move forward with their life.
At the end of the day, people make mistakes, misunderstandings happen, and sometimes innocent people are accused of crimes they didn’t commit. I don’t believe a single encounter with the criminal justice system should unnecessarily define someone’s career, reputation, or future. That’s why our mission at Texas Defenders goes beyond fighting criminal charges. We’re fighting to protect the opportunities our clients have worked their entire lives to build.
A criminal accusation does not have to define the rest of your life, provided you take deliberate steps to protect your rights from day one. As David Payma’s insights highlight, building a strong defense requires immediate investigation into police procedures, clear communication at every court setting, and a strategy that looks beyond the courtroom toward long-term record clearing.
Whether you are dealing with a DWI, drug allegation, assault charge, or weapons offense in North Texas, having an experienced legal team in your corner makes all the difference. Texas Defenders continues to set the standard for accessible, results-driven criminal defense across Dallas County and the greater DFW area, starting every case with a straightforward, free consultation.
To learn more, visit https://www.texasdefenders.com/dallas

